Very Good Is a Long Way from Perfect - Fear, Death, and the Logic of the Cross

Trouble in Paradise - Understanding Orthodoxy by Rethinking ... by Matthew Lyon

Episode notes

Episode 5 —

In Part 3, we follow the implications of one foundational question:

Did Genesis describe Adam as perfect — or as very good?

We explore how imagining a perfected Adam logically leads to:

  • Collapse/Corpse anthropology
  • Inability to will salvific good
  • Monergistic grace
  • Meticulous providence
  • The “inevitability instinct”
  • Intensified penal substitution

We then contrast this with the Orthodox diagnosis of the Fall as mortality, corruption, and fear of death — not metaphysical annihilation of the will.

It is an examination of premises.

Key Biblical Texts

  • Genesis 1:31 — “Very good” (tov me’od)
  • Romans 8:7–13 — “Those who are in the flesh cannot please God”
  • Hebr ... 
 ...  Read more
Keywords
augustineoriginal sinreformedorthodoxyorthodoxadam and evefree willdeterminismatheismgenesis