Caleb Flynn, The Tipp City, Ohio Resident Who Was Charged for Murdering His Wife While His Kids Were at the House. This killer who was a former American Idol Contestant murdered his wife while his kids were sleeping (as he said). He claims he was sleeping in his kids' room while an intruder entered his house and shot his wife twice in the head. Now, how did he know she was shot twice???? Listen to the previous recordings of this case, that includes his 911 call and his auditions from American Idol.