Gorgias the Nihilist

On a clear Athenian afternoon in the the late fifth century BCE, when the heat on the white stone steps of the law courts shimmered like water, a stranger from the West walked into the city and changed the sound of public speech. He came not in armor but in a richly woven cloak, with a small entourage and a reputation that had travelled ahead of him: a man whose words could dazzle crowds, unmake reputations, and twist the most settled opinions into something new. His name was Gorgias of Leontini, and for a brief, intense moment in the history of Greek thought, he stood at the center of a question that will haunt Western moral philosophy from then on: if language can make the weaker argument seem stronger, what becomes of truth and justice?

Gorgias was born around 485 BCE in Leontini, a Greek city in Sicily. Southern Italy and Sicily were, h ...