Episode 11- Why We Say "I'm Fine"...

Episode 11- Why We Say "I'm Fine" When We Are Not: The Psychology of Hiding Your True Feelings

The Original Self Podcast by Evet DeCota
S1 · E11
May 20, 2026
01:24:09

Episode notes

Most of us learned to say “I’m fine” long before we understood what it was costing us. In Episode 11 of The Original Self Podcast, Evet DeCota shares how a childhood bone disease, the loss of her best friend, and a love she was too armored to fight for all shaped her into someone who buried her feelings so deeply she eventually stopped feeling them altogether.

Then she’s joined by Jackson — her 17-year-old nephew — in one of the most honest conversations this podcast has ever held. Jackson lost his mother to colon cancer at fifteen, watched his family fracture in the aftermath, and spent years hiding behind humor, performance, and a persona built to keep people from getting too close. His first serious relationship cracked something open in him that grief alone couldn’t. And in this episode, he finally says it out loud.

This episode weaves personal story with psychology — including Erving Goffman’s concept of impression management, Dr. Brené Brown’s research on shame and armor, Arthur Aron’s self-expansion theory, Helen Fisher’s neuroscience of heartbreak, and Dr. James Pennebaker’s findings on the physical cost of emotional concealment.

What We Cover

• Why “I’m fine” becomes automatic — and what it protects us from

• How emotional suppression starts in childhood and hardens over time

• The neuroscience of heartbreak and why it feels physical

• What first love reveals about the self we’ve been hiding

• Why performing “fine” is armor — not resilience

• What exists on the other side of fine: the quiet relief of being known

Researchers & Concepts Referenced

• Erving Goffman — Impression Management / The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life

• Dr. Brené Brown — Shame, Vulnerability, and Armor

• Arthur Aron — Self-Expansion Theory and Love

• Helen Fisher — The Neuroscience of Heartbreak and Love as Addiction

• Dr. James Pennebaker — Emotional Suppression and Physical Health

Reflection Question

Who in your life would make time for your truth — but you keep giving them “fine” instead? What would it cost you to tell them one real thing this week?

Connect & Work With Evet

Website: www.decotalifecoaching.com

Instagram: @decotalifecoaching.com

Keywords

self-awareness
psychology podcast
emotional suppression
impression management
first love
vulnerability
emotional concealment
teen mental health
se;f-expansion