In this episode, we take on one of the biggest discussions in the book world right now: the controversy around Alchemised, the book igniting conversations about people’s (lack of) support for Harry Potter and its related fanfiction in 2025.

Kristin is back on the podcast! Our conversation starts with thoughts on the recent trailer for “Wuthering Heights” (2026) before we jump into the messy intersection of nostalgia, fandom, and accountability. Why do we still feel connected to certain stories? How do we handle authors whose beliefs don’t align with ours? Is it actually possible to separate the art from the artist?

What does reading looking like in 2025, and how can fandoms reckon with their roots?

Grab your tea, get comfy, and join us for a candid, thoughtful chat about the complicated joy of loving stories th ...