Episode notes
Family Guy Season 2 Episode 2 "Holy Crap" recap and review: Jason, Tyler, and Collin break down Peter Griffin kidnapping the Pope to impress his terrifying Catholic dad, and the episode somehow goes off the rails from there.
The guys meet Grandpa Griffin for the first time, voiced by two-time Oscar nominee Charles Durning, and watch Peter get desperate enough for his father's approval to commit a federal crime. Along the way they get into the Janet Jackson unc shooting poison, Rosie O'Donnell's 1999 WAP era, the concept of Ma, the 2026 Religion Draft, why Mr. Weed might be the best character on the show, Tyler's first Hinge date in two and a half years, the structurehead vs gagger divide, and whether Dick Van Dyke is swagless or still chopped.
Family Guy Guys is a comedy rewatch podcast where three improv comedian friends watch every single Family Guy episode in order, clip by clip, with zero pretense and even less structure. New episodes drop on YouTube.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Intro and the Werevert bit
16:38 Episode intro: "Holy Crap" (September 30, 1999)
25:39 Writer Danny Smith and Grandpa Griffin
35:53 The musical cue gag
37:04 Logic ft. Seth MacFarlane
41:54 Florence Stanley and Dinosaurs
51:50 Growing up religious and the 2026 Religion Draft
57:33 Chris, God, and the bathroom
01:02:00 Benny Hinn televangelist spiral
01:07:55 Fenway and Peter's desperation
01:10:38 Dick Van Dyke Show physical comedy
01:13:41 Tyler's Hinge date
01:17:00 The date roleplay
01:19:18 Examine This Cock
01:22:09 Rosie O'Donnell's WAP era
01:26:17 Sanford and Son and blackface
01:28:59 Daniel Day-Lewis peptide biopic
01:30:45 Mr. Weed and the prostate joke
01:36:05 Employee of the Week: Jesus
01:42:18 Peter stands up to Francis
01:52:39 The waffle iron gag
01:54:25 Peter kidnaps the Pope
01:56:12 The airplane Ma gag
02:00:18 "I love you, I just don't like you"
02:05:20 The Memento date bit
02:07:42 Final ratings
Would you tell your first date in two and a half years that you host a Family Guy rewatch podcast? Send the damage to feedback@familyguyguys.com or visit https://familyguyguys.com.
This podcast is not affiliated with Seth MacFarlane, Fox, or the Catholic Church. We are three guys who watch a cartoon. Please do not tell the Pope about us.
Feedback: feedback@familyguyguys.com
#FamilyGuy #FamilyGuyGuys #HolyCrap #Rewatch