Dad, You're Wrong - Episode 2: Shelby Oaks (2025)

EPISODE 2: "Shelby Oaks"

Chris Stuckmann's feature debut Shelby Oaks (2025) finally arrives, and we have very different reactions. Produced by Mike Flanagan and years in the making, this found-footage film about a missing paranormal investigation team has divided audiences - and us.

We dig into the first act's promise versus the third act's delivery, debate whether YouTuber-to-filmmaker transitions can work, and confront the elephant in the room: hellhounds and flashlights. One of us is putting it in our top ten. The other is calling it the most disappointing film of the year.

Plus: DIY Halloween costume breakdown featuring an Exorcist priest with authentic pea soup vomit recipe.

Eric's Rating: Theater Josh's Rating: Nyquil