In 1997, 52-year-old diner owner Dorothy Wenzel was brutally murdered outside the West Wind Diner near Darien, Wisconsin. Within days, police arrested two teenagers and uncovered a planned robbery that ended in a deadly baseball bat attack. Nearly three decades later, confusion still surrounds how the case was solved. Among Monsters examines the crime, the confessions, the evidence, and the choices that turned an ordinary night at a small-town diner into tragedy.