Prepare for a clash of post-grunge titans as two of the most polarizing, arena-filling albums from the heyday of radio-friendly “butt rock” go head-to-head in a battle of anthems, angst, and unapologetic power chords.

Nickelback – Silver Side Up (2001)

Creed – Human Clay (1999)

Other Diggins

The Band Feel – Into the Sun (EP) 2025

D’Angelo – Black Messiah (2014)

Alison Krauss & Union Station – Arcadia (2025)

Billy Idol – Dream Into It (2025)

What do you think of these records? Which record do you think comes out on top? Let us know on our website, albumnerds.com or email us, podcast@albumnerds.com.

Listen to a ...