Judges on Civility, Credibility, ...

Judges on Civility, Credibility, and the Future of the Jury Trial

ABOTA Speaks by American Board of Trial Advocates
S2 · E3
Feb 4, 2026
21:44

Episode notes

In this episode of ABOTA Speaks, host Jill Webb is joined by U.S. Judge Robert L. Pitman of the Western District of Texas, U.S. Chief Judge Amos L. Mazzant III, of the Eastern District of Texas, and Justice Chari L. Kelly for the Texas Third Court of Appeals for a candid conversation about jury trials—from the perspective of the bench.

Drawing on their collective experience, these judges discuss openly how jurors experience the courtroom, what builds or erodes credibility, and why civility and professionalism remain essential to the future of the jury trial.

Their conversation explores how jurors perceive attorneys and witnesses, the subtle details that influence trust, and the responsibility lawyers share in maintaining confidence in the justice system. Along the way, the judges offer thoughtful observations and real-world examples that underscore just how closely juries are paying attention.

This episode offers valuable insight for trial lawyers and anyone interested in the evolving role of juries and the enduring importance of credibility in the courtroom.

ABOTA Speaks releases new episodes every two weeks.

Support the podcast: Subscribe on YouTube, follow us on your favorite podcast app, share this episode or leave a review on Apple Podcasts. We want others to discover these great conversations!

Learn more about ABOTA: www.abota.org

Keywords

civility
future of the justice system
civil jury trial
ABOTA Speaks
justice system
leadership in the courtroom
Chari Kelly
Amos Mazzant
Robert Pitman