Episode notes
We've done this exercise before, for Chris Olave. The exercise, now known as: The 28 to 3 Pod "Game Show" has proven to be one of our favorite, and maybe most effective, ways of determining exactly where a player ranks league-wide, despite our biased feelings (rightfully so) as Saints fans who may have trouble separating our positive (or negative) feelings from any given hometown player.
So, we put Derek Carr through the game show process. In his case, it obviously seems like the majority of Who Dats have negative feelings towards Carr (to put it lightly), leading many to say they'd rather anyone else under center. But, when compared head to head against every other starting QB's in the league, would that be justified? Maybe it is., maybe it isn't - maybe...the answer isn't black and white.
After we go through every starting NFL QB and simply say "Yes or No" to him or Carr, we feel confident the picture behind that answer will be more clear. This was definitely a fun and maybe even enlightening episode. LISTEN IN! WHO DAT?!