On Christmas Eve, 1945, the Sodder family home in Fayetteville, West Virginia went up in flames.

By morning, five children were gone.

Officials ruled the case simple: the children perished in the fire.

But no remains were ever conclusively identified.

The phone line had been cut. The ladder was missing. The trucks wouldn’t start. Witnesses claimed to see the children alive in the days that followed. And the parents never stopped searching.

In this episode of THE PINE GROVE BRIAR, we examine one of America’s most enduring mysteries — the disappearance of the Sodder children. Through period newspaper accounts, conflicting fire science, eyewitness claims, and decades of unanswered questions, this story refuses to settle into a single explanation.

Did five children die in a tragic Christmas fire? ...