PRIDE, Crime & Story Time
Season 1
Last Call: The Pattern Emerges (Part 2)
Last Call: The First Two Stories (Part 1)
Sage Smith: A Future Stolen
Stonewall: The Night That Changed History
The Investigation: The Sam Nordquist Case (Part 2)
by Kylie
Episode 6: Last Call – The Pattern Emerges (Part 2) Content Warning: This episode contains discussions of murder, violence, dismemberment, addiction, discrimination against the LGBTQ community, and other sensitive topics that may not be suitable for all listeners. As investigators struggle to solve the murders of Peter Anderson and Thomas Mulcahy, another man will disappear. In Part 2 of our Last Call series, we remember the lives of Anthony Edward Marrero and Michael J. Sakara—two men from very different backgrounds. As evidence begins to connect the cases, a multi-state task force is formed, the LGBTQ community rallies together, and detectives begin searching for a killer who seems to vanish without a trace. This isn't just the story of a serial killer. It's the story of four men whose lives mattered long before they became victims or another news story. In This Episode The life of Anthony Edward Marrero The life of Michael J. Sakara How investigators connected the murders The formation of a multi-state task force The Anti-Violence Project's efforts to protect the LGBTQ community The investigation grows—but the killer still remains unidentified Sources Last Call: A True Story of Love, Lust, and Murder in Queer New York by Elon Green Last Call: When a Serial Killer Stalked Queer New York (Max Original Documentary) Contemporary news reports and court records
In the early 1990s, New York City's LGBTQ community was searching for connection during one of its darkest chapters. Amid the AIDS crisis, neighborhood bars became places to gather, build friendships, relationships and just belonging. Then men began disappearing. In Part 1 of our three-part series on Last Call, we step away from the headlines and focus on the lives of Peter Stickney Anderson and Thomas Richard Mulcahy—two men whose stories deserve to be remembered long before they became victims and newspaper headlines. As investigators struggle to make sense of two brutal murders, the first hints of a terrifying pattern begin to emerge. Content Warning: This episode contains discussions of murder, violence, dismemberment, and anti-LGBTQ discrimination that may be disturbing to some listeners. Sources Last Call: A True Story of Love, Lust, and Murder in Queer New York by Elon Green Last Call: When a Serial Killer Stalked Queer New York (Max Original Documentary Series) If you enjoyed this episode, please consider following Pride, Crime & Story Time, leaving a rating or review, and sharing the show with someone who enjoys thoughtful true crime, LGBTQ+ history, and the stories behind the headlines. 🎙️🏳️🌈
At just 19 years old, Sage Smith was finally beginning to build the life she had always dreamed of. She was studying cosmetology, embracing her identity as a transgender woman, and looking forward to her future. Then, she disappeared after leaving to meet someone. More than a decade later, Sage is still missing, her family is still searching for answers, and one of the most heartbreaking unsolved cases involving a young Black transgender woman remains unresolved. In this episode of Pride, Crime & Story Time, we honor Sage's life, examine the investigation, and discuss why every missing person deserves equal attention, compassion, and justice. 🎙️🏳️🌈
Stonewall: The Night That Changed History What really happened outside the Stonewall Inn in June 1969? In this episode of Pride, Crime & Story Time, we explore the events that sparked one of the most significant moments in LGBTQIA+ history. From years of police raids and discrimination to the nights that changed everything, we look beyond the headlines to understand why Stonewall became a turning point in the fight for equality. We'll discuss: The atmosphere leading up to the Stonewall Uprising What happened during the first nights of resistance How Stonewall inspired the modern LGBTQIA+ rights movement Why its legacy still matters today Whether you're hearing this story for the first time or revisiting a defining moment in history, this episode honors the resilience, courage, and community that helped change the world. 🌈🎙️ Thank you for listening to Pride, Crime & Story Time. If you enjoyed this episode, please consider following the podcast, leaving a review, and sharing it with someone who loves history and meaningful storytelling.
This episode includes discussions of torture, sexual assault, and murder. Listener discretion is strongly advised. In Part 2 of the Sam Nordquist case, we pick up where we left off. As investigators begin uncovering the truth, interviews, search warrants, digital evidence, and witness statements reveal the horrific abuse Sam endured during the final 127 days of his life. This episode covers: The investigation that unraveled the suspects' stories The discovery of Sam's body The arrests of all seven defendants The charges and recent plea agreements Why this case has been described as one of the worst investigators have ever seen As always, our focus is on remembering Sam—not for the cruelty he endured, but for the life he lived, the kindness he shared, and the people who loved him. Thank you for joining me for the first episode of Pride, Crime & Story Time, where we explore true crime, history, LGBTQIA+ stories, and the people behind them—because every story deserves to be heard. Follow so you never miss an episode. ⭐ If you enjoyed the show, please leave a rating and review—it helps more people discover these stories. 📱 Follow the podcast on Instagram, TikTok, Facebook: @PrideCrimeStoryTime (YoutTube) coming soon... Sources: Glaad.org (https://glaad.org/grief-and-fond-remembrances-for-slain-transgender-man-sam-nordquist/) https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/sam-nordquist-killing-room-22-rcna194129 https://www.syracuse.com/crime/2026/06/the-leader-in-killing-of-sam-nordquist-faces-life-in-prison-but-the-death-penalty-remains-a-threat.html https://13wham.com/news/local/suspect-in-transgender-mans-murder-accused-of-attacking-inmate-at-ontario-county-jail-jennifer-quijano-sam-nordquist https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/sam-nordquist-killing-room-22-rcna194129 https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=539445755860034 https://www.syracuse.com/news/2026/04/accused-finger-lakes-killers-left-a-brazen-trail-of-depravity-and-red-flags-new-documents-show.html&subscribed=auth0%7C6a579453c5d59a7be2190ff1
Sam Nordquist: A Life Taken Too Soon 🏳️⚧️ In this episode of Pride, Crime & Story Time, we remember Sam Nordquist—a young transgender man whose life was cut tragically short way too soon. Together, we'll explore who Sam was beyond the headlines and the timeline of his disappearance. This episode contains discussion of violence that may be difficult for some listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Every victim has a story. Every voice deserves to be heard. Every story has a home. 🎙️ Follow Pride, Crime & Story Time wherever you listen to podcasts. 🏳️🌈 If you enjoyed this episode, please consider leaving a rating and review—it helps others discover the show. Follow us on social media for episode updates, behind-the-scenes content, and additional photos and sources. #TrueCrime #SamNordquist #JusticeForSam #LGBTQ #TransRights #History #PrideCrimeStoryTime