Brandon Swanson vanished in the early hours of May 14, 2008—and nearly two decades later, there are still no answers.

After Brandon's car became stuck in a ditch, he called his parents for help. What followed was an unsettling phone call that lasted nearly 47 minutes as Brandon tried to make his way toward what he believed was a nearby town.

Then he said something that would become forever etched into the case: “Oh, shit.” The line went silent.

Despite extensive searches, Brandon was never found. His vehicle was recovered, but the questions surrounding his final moments remain.

Did Brandon become disoriented in unfamiliar terrain? Did something happen to him along the way? Or is there something about that final phone call that we've overlooked?

Join Jenie and Tyler on Paired Nightmares as we unravel the disappearance ...