It's the Greatest Show, Man!
Season 4
The Phantom of the Opera
Season 4 Teaser
Season 3
Here We Are
White Christmas
La La Land
Starship
Wicked
Heathers
Tarzan
The Civil War
1 of 4
by Emily Schiavone and Brandtly Wheeler
It's Season 4, and we're back with a doozy! In a much anticipated episode, Emily and Brandtly are covering the longest running Broadway show of all time, Andrew Lloyd Webber's Phantom of the Opera! But what do they REALLY think about this undeniable musical smash? Does it soar higher than an E6 or does it need to go back to the sewers where it belongs? Slap on your half-mask, lock your girlfriend in your underground lair, grab your popcorn, and listen now! This episode was recorded on July 12, 2026. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
We're back! (And it's been a long summer.) Season 4 begins on September 14th, 2026. Until then, enjoy the Season 3 outtakes. See you soon!
It's the Season 3 Finale! This week, Emily and Brandtly explore the last work of the late great Stephen Sondheim, Here We Are. Do we sense some Hesitation? Or does this show really Shine? CONTENT WARNING: This episode discusses death, loss, and suicidal ideation. This episode was recorded on December 28, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
Merry Christmas from the Greatest Show Pod! This week, Emily and Brandtly discuss the Irving Berlin holiday classic, White Christmas. Will this show have us Counting Our Blessings or Wishing We Were Back in the Army? Listen now! (PS: We got carried away singing parody songs at the end and forgot to rate the show #noregrets. It's an 8/10 for both of us.) This episode was recorded on December 21, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
It's just Another Day of Sun! Or is it? Your hosts Emily and Brandtly discuss the award-winning musical film, La La Land, starring Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone, Did they have A Lovely Night, or did it make them want to Start a Fire? Listen now! This episode was recorded on December 13, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
Do you wanna be a Starship Ranger? If you answered yes, then do we have the show for you! This week, Brandtly and Emily tackle the high-flying space adventure, Starship by Team StarKid. Does this sci-fi epic keep the Status Quo or do we need to Kick It Up a Notch? Listen now! This episode was recorded on November 22, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
Nobody in all of Oz (no wizard that there is or was) is ever gonna bring us down this week! Brandtly and Emily discuss the hit Broadway musical Wicked ahead of the new movie release. Will this episode be Popular? Or will it be Something Bad (aka the most skippable track on the album)? Listen now! This episode was recorded on November 7, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
Shut up, Heather! The newest episode of the Greatest Show Pod is out now! This time, Brandtly and Emily cover the Off-Broadway cult classic, Heathers: The Musical. Is it Big Fun, or will it make you want to Freeze Your Brain? (Also, Happy Musical Reveal Week to all who celebrate! We hope you find the hints for the 2026 Spring show!) This episode was recorded on October 4, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
Hold on to your loin cloths, because this week we are swinging on vines and yelling about Tarzan! Emily and Brandtly discuss the fascinating choices that were made when this musical was produced for Broadway. Will this show be in our hearts? Or is it just to Different for us to love? #justicefortantor This episode was recorded on August 9, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube
The greatest tragedy in American history... or just the greatest tragedy to befall Broadway? Join us this week as Brandtly and Emily discuss this Frank Wildhorn flop. Should I Tell My Father about this show, or will it Never Pass This Way Again? Listen now! This episode was recorded on July 30, 2025. Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show! Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire: patrickduffymusic.com Instagram YouTube