The hosts discuss their top games from 2013, focusing on their number four and five picks. They analyze their experiences with Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, Payday 2, Lego Marvel Super Heroes, Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag, BioShock Infinite, and State of Decay. The conversation covers gameplay mechanics, narrative structure, performance issues across consoles, and the disappointment of missing features like online multiplayer in specific titles.