Welcome to the first episode of Dueling Daddies, the bite-sized Gaymer Daddies spin-off where two daddies square off over food, a two-player board game and a piece of pop culture. Each contender receives a letter grade before we reveal our final Daddy Report Cards.

In this episode:

• BITE ME DADDY — We taste Jimmy John’s new PB&J Cookie, a soft-baked peanut butter cookie filled with grape jelly and topped with crunchy peanuts. Does this childhood favorite deserve a spot in our lunchbox, or should Jimmy John’s stick to sandwiches?

• DADDY DUEL — We go undercover with Agent Avenue, a two-player game of bluffing, deduction and double-crossing. We break down how it plays, what makes its face-up-or-face-down card choices so tense and whether this neighborhood is big enough for both of our spies.

• DADDY CULTURE CLUB — We he ...