Round 12 delivered massive storylines, coaching speculation and some of the biggest debates of the AFL season so far.

This week on Between The Sticks, the boys break down Carlton’s resurgence, Collingwood’s concerns, Essendon’s coaching future and the ongoing debate around AFL rules and umpiring.

We ask:

Who should be Essendon’s next coach? Should James Hird return, or do the Bombers need a fresh start?

Should Ross Lyon and St Kilda be under more pressure?

Are Carlton officially back? After a huge win over Geelong under Josh Fraser, are the Blues a genuine finals threat or just enjoying a new coach bounce?

Are Collingwood in trouble? With injuries mounting and Nick Daicos carrying a heavy load, can the Pies still contend or is  ...