In the premiere episode of True, False, or Fatal, host Tanner Blake Adams drives into one of America's most haunting unsolved cases; the 1988 disappearance of Tara Calico. What began as a bike ride in New Mexico quickly turned into a decades long mystery filled with strange clues, chilling witness reports, and a disturbing Polaroid that may hold the key to the truth.

With four call-ins offering their own theories, suspicions rise and tensions build as each perspective challenges what really happened that day. Was Tara the victim of a random abduction? A targeted crime? Or something even darker?

As the debate unfolds, only one question remains: is the story True, False... or Fatal?

Tune in and decide for yourself.