In Episode 12 of the Starbuck & Sargent Podcast, James Starbuck and Herb Sargent tackle one of the hardest leadership questions in construction: what do you do with high-performing employees who are toxic to the team?

Jimmy shares the story of a “unicorn” operator — one of the most talented machine operators he had ever seen — who could produce incredible results, but slowly damaged morale, training, standards, and the wider crew culture. Herb shares his own experience of letting go of two excavator operators within 16 hours to protect the standards and culture of his business.

The conversation explores why production alone is not enough, why some of the people who helped build your company can eventually hold it back, and why leaders must be willing to make hard decisions when culture, accountability, and long-term business healt ...