Episode 39: MURDERED: Lucy Dade Forrester - Frankfort, NY

A quiet village in upstate New York. A trusted shopkeeper who never turned anyone away. And a brutal murder that shattered a community and was never solved. Who killed Lucy Dade Forrester?

Episode Summary

Lucy Dade Forrester was a 69-year-old shop owner in the village of Frankfort, New York. She lived alone above the small variety store she had worked hard to build, a place where locals knew her as kind, dependable, and always willing to help. Lucy had a reputation for opening her door after hours if someone knocked, no matter the time. It was simply who she was.

On the night of February 19, 1964, Lucy was last seen alive inside her store on South Litchfield Street. Sometime overnight, someone came to her door. Inves ...