Episode 29: MURDERED: Katherine “Katy” Coffee – Newcastle, WY

A promising life cut short in a quiet Wyoming town. A devoted conservationist, new beginnings, and a cold case that shook a community for years. When answers finally came, they still didn’t explain everything, and Katy’s family is left with both justice and heartbreak.

Episode Summary

In June 2011, 35-year-old Katherine “Katy” Coffee was found murdered inside her home in Newcastle, Wyoming. Katy had recently moved there from her hometown of Canadian, Texas, excited to start a new chapter working as a district conservationist with the USDA. She was known for her kindness, her passion for helping farmers and ranchers, and the way she threw her whole heart into her work.

Her murder stunned the town. For more than fo ...