Shipwrecked thousands of miles from land in the middle of the Pacific, the survivors of the whaleship Essex faced a choice of which way to row. Out of a baseless fear of cannibals, they chose the longer, deadlier route, and in doing so were driven to become cannibals themselves.

This episode dives into the real 1820 disaster that inspired Moby Dick, a story far darker and more human than the fiction. We explore the leadership failures of a teenage crew, the science behind a sperm whale ramming a ship, and how fear of the unknown proved deadlier than the dangers they could actually see.

• Why the youthful command of 29-year-old Captain Pollard repeatedly caved to his ambitious 21-year-old first mate Owen Chase
• The acoustic theory that hammering repairs on the hull mimicked a rival whale's clicks, provoking the 85-foot bull t ...