It is difficult to read a passage like the one in Genesis 34 and find God’s inspiration. It is a hard story to comprehend when we believe it to be the revealed word of God and yet struggle to find any hope in it. Catholics and Jews find this one particularly vexing and would just as soon skip over it. Because it is so difficult we confront it. Rabbi Fruithandler and Barbara Murphy wrestle with the question, where is God in this?