Five-year-old Kamarie Holland should have had her entire life ahead of her.

Instead, her name became connected to one of the most disturbing child-murder cases in Alabama and Georgia.

In this deeply researched episode of You Can’t Make This Bs Up!, we go beyond the headlines to reconstruct the story from the beginning: Kamarie’s childhood and family, Jeremy Tremaine Williams’s documented history, Kristy Siple’s role, the relationships and warning signs that preceded the crime, the investigation, the forensic evidence, Williams’s confession, the courtroom proceedings, and the death sentence that followed.

We also examine the difficult questions surrounding Williams’s earlier history, including the 2009 child-abuse case that ended in an acquittal, the investigation into the 2005 death of his infant daughter Naudia, and testimony c ...