As darkness falls over Nebraska, one driver’s ordinary night turns bone-chilling. In this Halloween special, Jordan and Patrice read a true story from Reddit about a mysterious family walking down a pitch-black rural road, complete with an empty stroller and synchronized stares that’ll haunt your imagination. They dive into real-life encounters, eerie coincidences, and listener stories that blur the line between creepy coincidence and the supernatural.

If you love tales that make you glance over your shoulder or wonder what’s lurking beyond your headlights, this one’s for you.