This episode, The Brothers Grimm and Grimmer are heading to Amity Island to ask the important questions: Why is everyone so chill about a giant man-eating shark? How many bad decisions can one mayor make? And was Quint secretly fueled by nothing but coffee, sea salt, and pure spite?

Join us as we sink our teeth into Jaws, the movie that traumatized beachgoers, convinced millions that every shadow in the water was coming for them, and proved that sometimes the scariest thing in the ocean is local government.