In 427 BC, Athens voted to massacre the entire population of Mytilene, and then voted again. This is the story of that second vote, and what is meant.

The Mytilenean Debate is one of the most important political exchanges in ancient history. Thucydides records it in full in Book 3 of his History of the Peloponnesian War: a confrontation between Cleon, the most powerful demagogue in Athens, and Diodotus, an unknown figure who appears once, delivers one of the most sophisticated arguments in ancient Greek political thought, and then disappears from the historical record entirely.

Diodotus didn't argue that killing thousands of innocent people was wrong. He argued it was bad strategy. Facing an assembly still hot with rage, post-plague, post-Pericles, and deep into the first years of the Peloponnesian War, he knew that mercy cou ...