Separate Feeding Stations vs Shared Bowls: Which Works Better for Dogs and Cats Living Together Verdict: Separate feeding stations win for most multi-species households, especially when you're dealing with size differences, food aggression potential, or species-specific dietary needs between dogs and cats. I've lived with four dogs for years, and even within a single species, feeding time can turn chaotic without clear boundaries. When you add cats to the mix—with their grazing habits, slower eating pace, and completely different nutritional requirements—feeding multiple pets separately becomes less about preference and more about safety and health. This comparison breaks down the practical realities of both approaches: the space requirements, behavioral considerations, cost differences, and daily workflow of managing meals in a multi-pet home ...