On April 11, 1981, something horrifying happened insideCabin 28 in the small California town of Keddie. By the next morning, SueSharp, her son John, and his friend Dana Wingate were dead—and 12-year-old TinaSharp was missing.

What followed was a decades-long mystery filled withconflicting witness statements, possible suspects, a mysterious green van, amissing hammer, alleged confessions, and questions about whether the originalinvestigation failed to uncover the truth.

Tina's remains wouldn't be discovered until 1984, but thequestions surrounding that night are still unanswered.

Who killed Sue, John, and Dana? What happened to Tina? Anddid investigators overlook the people responsible?

Join Jenie and Tyler on Paired Nightmares as we stepinside one of California's most disturbing unsolved cases.