The murder of Jodi Jones, a 14-year-old girl, took place in Dalkeith, Scotland on 30 June 2003. Her 15-year-old boyfriend, Luke Mitchell, came under suspicion, but it was several months before he was arrested.

Mitchell was tried for the murder and after Scotland's longest single-accused trial, Mitchell was convicted in January 2005 despite there being no direct evidence against him.

He was sentenced to detention without limit of time with a minimum of 20 years. Mitchell continues to protest his innocence and has insisted he will only walk out of prison a free man. He will not accept liability for early release or parole.

Is this another miscarriage of Justice? Is he guilty or Innocent?