In June 1989, a vacation to the Sunshine State turned into a waking nightmare for Jo, Michelle, and Christe Rodgers. What was meant to be a celebratory trip from their family farm in Ohio ended in a discovery that shocked the nation: three bodies found floating in Tampa Bay, bound and weighted with concrete blocks.

In this episode, Evelyn Black dives deep into one of Florida’s most haunting cold cases. We trace the family's final steps, from their confusion navigating the Florida backroads to the chance encounter with a "helpful" local that sealed their fate.

What We Cover:

• The Vanishing: How a wrong turn led the Rodgers women to a boat slip and a predator waiting in the shadows.
• The Forensic Breakthrough: The incredible story of how a hand-written  ...