In 1974, two men vanished in Iceland. Eighteen-year-old Guðmundur Einarsson disappeared after a night out, and months later, 32-year-old Geirfinnur Einarsson vanished after a phone call drew him to Keflavík harbor. Neither man was ever found. What followed was one of the most controversial criminal cases in European history: six confessions, no bodies, no forensic proof, and convictions that later collapsed. In this episode, we trace the disappearances, the pressure-filled investigation, and the questions that still remain.