In 1993, Amarillo lawyer David Glenn Lewis vanished, leaving behind a home that suggested he planned to return. His watch and wedding ring were on the counter, sandwiches were in the fridge, and the VCR kept recording the Super Bowl after he was gone. Then, less than two days later, an unidentified man was killed on a highway near Moxee, Washington. It would take eleven years to learn they were the same person. In this episode, we trace the strange timeline, the missing hours, and the unanswered question at the center of the case: how did David Glenn Lewis end up 1,600 miles from home?