In the early hours of June 2, 2009, during a thunderstorm, someone entered a home in the Amish community through an unlocked basement door and fired one bullet upon a sleeping Amish mother of five. The police would soon have a suspect in sight and expose his secret life as the Amish Stud.

A Killing in Amish Country By: Gregg Olsen and Rebecca Morris

ID's Murder in Amish County episode "The Amish Stud" S1 E3